« Lessons for BYU: UCLA vs. Tennessee - What if the SEC, Big 12, and Pac Ten champs are undefeated… »

Ohio State casserole…

14 September 2008

As I watched the Buckeye offense flounder against USC, I couldn’t shake the question:  Who are these guys trying to be?

With USC, it’s clear; they are optimized for a pro-style offense, with a line that can protect a pocket, a quarterback who can read coverages, and a play-caller who uses his talent within that scheme.  It’s the same with West Virginia, optimized for the spread-option in focus, personnel, and play-calling.

But Ohio State is a casserole.  They run a little pro, a little spread-option, a little this, a little that…  They are pretty good at a lot of things, but not excellent at any one thing.

For example, they asked their classic drop-back passer, Todd Boeckman, to run some spread-option plays against the Trojans, which is like asking a dump truck to win the Daytona 500.  It was sad to watch him get pounded with no chance for a decent gain.  Those were wasted plays that served only to fire up USC’s defense and home crowd.

Against lesser competition, a patchwork offense works just fine because Ohio State’s overall talent level is greater.  But against the likes of USC and LSU, being a jack of all styles – instead of a master of one — has not served the Buckeyes well.


Leave a reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.